Mon, May
76 New Articles

ECJ’s Ruling in Favour of Boehringer - Pharmaceutical Companies May Retroactively Reduce Their VAT Liabilities

ECJ’s Ruling in Favour of Boehringer - Pharmaceutical Companies May Retroactively Reduce Their VAT Liabilities

  • Smaller Small Medium Big Bigger
  • Default Helvetica Segoe Georgia Times

The Hungarian State unlawfully collected a sizeable amount of VAT from pharmaceutical companies ruled the European Court of Justice (ECJ) in a recent preliminary ruling procedure, initiated by Boehringer Ingelheim against the Hungarian tax authority.

Basing its decision on the principle of fiscal neutrality, the ECJ stated that “the amount collected by the tax authorities must not exceed the amount paid by the final consumer, i.e. Member States are obliged to reduce the taxable amount in all cases where the taxable person does not receive the whole or part of the consideration after the transaction has been completed”.

The judgement may affect numerous pharmaceutical companies in Hungary, since the background of the case lies in the reimbursement system of medicinal products, one method of which is based on a contractual relationship (so called subsidy volume contract or “támogatás volumen szerződések” in Hungarian) between the pharmaceutical company and the National Health Insurance Fund of Hungary (NEAK). Following the ECJ judgment, it is now clear that pharmaceutical companies are entitled to reduce their VAT with the amount paid to the NEAK under these contracts.

The ECJ also ruled in a separate question that VAT reduction must not be conditional on the availability of an invoice where no such invoice has been issued and where the completion of that transaction can be proved by other means, such as the payment notifications issued by the NEAK.

As a result of this decision by the ECJ, the Hungarian tax authority became obliged to reimburse approximately one million Euro to Boehringer Ingelheim.

Further to this recent decision, Hungarian pharmaceutical companies that had entered into similar subsidy volume contracts may potentially seek reimbursement of the VAT amount they have overpaid within the statutory limitation period (i.e. over the past five years) within a six-month window via a special self-revision.

By Eszter Kamocsay-Berta, Managing Partner, KCG Partners Law Firm

Hungary Knowledge Partner

Nagy és Trócsányi was founded in 1991, turned into limited professional partnership (in Hungarian: ügyvédi iroda) in 1992, with the aim of offering sophisticated legal services. The firm continues to seek excellence in a comprehensive and modern practice, which spans international commercial and business law. 

The firm’s lawyers provide clients with advice and representation in an active, thoughtful and ethical manner, with a real understanding of clients‘ business needs and the markets in which they operate.

The firm is one of the largest home-grown independent law firms in Hungary. Currently Nagy és Trócsányi has 26 lawyers out of which there are 8 active partners. All partners are equity partners.

Nagy és Trócsányi is a legal entity and registered with the Budapest Bar Association. All lawyers of the Budapest office are either members of, or registered as clerks with, the Budapest Bar Association. Several of the firm’s lawyers are admitted attorneys or registered as legal consultants in New York.

The firm advises a broad range of clients, including numerous multinational corporations. 

Our activity focuses on the following practice areas: M&A, company law, litigation and dispute resolution, real estate law, banking and finance, project financing, insolvency and restructuring, venture capital investment, taxation, competition, utilities, energy, media and telecommunication.

Nagy és Trócsányi is the exclusive member firm in Hungary for Lex Mundi – the world’s leading network of independent law firms with in-depth experience in 100+countries worldwide.

The firm advises a broad range of clients, including numerous multinational corporations. Among our key clients are: OTP Bank, Sberbank, Erste Bank, Scania, KS ORKA, Mannvit, DAF Trucks, Booking.com, Museum of Fine Arts of Budapest, Hungarian Post Pte Ltd, Hiventures, Strabag, CPI Hungary, Givaudan, Marks & Spencer, CBA.

Firm's website.

Our Latest Issue